R Kelly in Legal Trouble Again
Sept. 27, 2021, vii:00 p.k. ET
R. Kelly is going to prison house. Why did it take so long?
Video
transcript
transcript
R. Kelly Found Guilty on All Counts
The singer was convicted of federal racketeering and sex trafficking charges for a decades-long scheme to recruit women and underage girls for sex. Once one of the biggest names in popular music, he could face up decades in prison house.
-
"Today's guilty verdict forever brands R. Kelly as a predator who used his fame and fortune to casualty on the young, the vulnerable and the voiceless." "Mr. Kelly is a prolific series predator. Despite numerous reports of his subversive abuse over the years, Mr. Kelly's brazen acts of intimidation confronting his accusers kept him shielded from prosecution." "Kelly, later on grooming, isolating and intimidating his child victims, recorded them being sexually abused and humiliated past him. He directed these videos and produced them, non only for his ain sexual gratification, but in some instances for the purpose of using these videos to silence and threaten his victims with public exposure of these tapes if they ever revealed what he had done to them." "Of course, Mr. Kelly is disappointed. He was not anticipating this verdict because based on the show, why should he anticipate this verdict? I'm certain — I'm certain we'll be appealing."
The conviction of R. Kelly on all 9 counts against him came as a meaning moment in the Me Likewise move for both Black women and for the music manufacture, ushering in a sense that, finally, justice had been served.
But the verdict on Monday also prompted an obvious question: Women take said that the vocalizer's abuses began equally early as the start of the 1990s — why did it take iii decades for the singer to receive criminal penalization?
Hither are a few possible answers:
The entertainer had an expansive network of enablers effectually him, federal prosecutors said, from his closest confidantes and employees to many in the music industry who knew of the concerns about his behavior merely did not intervene.
The government drew attention to what has been described as the "settlement factory" that kept his accusers tranquility, offering evidence of Mr. Kelly's payments to women who made accusations in exchange for their silence.
And when that was not enough, Mr. Kelly "used his henchmen to gild threats and exact revenge," blackmailing women with nude photographs of themselves or embarrassing information, i prosecutor, Elizabeth Geddes, said in closing arguments.
Federal prosecutors also accused Mr. Kelly of paying witnesses to not cooperate with the authorities in the lead-up to his 2008 trial and acquittal. They said the singer allow some witnesses know they could exist "subject area to physical harm" if they proceeded.
There are some cultural factors that may have helped Mr. Kelly avoid consequences for his behavior besides.
Legal experts and people who study sexual corruption have likewise suggested that the race of virtually of Mr. Kelly's accusers likely played a role. Experts say Blackness women have historically been far more likely than white women to have their accusations most sexual misconduct distrusted or ignored.
"Our reality is that our lodge simply does not view Blackness women and girls equally credible," said Kenyette Barnes, a co-founder of the #MuteRKelly campaign. "We assume that 15-yr-old Black girls have the cognitive ability to manipulate a grown human being."
And some superstars take admitted that the race of the accusers shaped their perceptions in Mr. Kelly'south case.
"I didn't value the accusers' stories considering they were Blackness women," Run a risk the Rapper, who is from the singer's hometown, Chicago, said during the "Surviving R. Kelly" documentary serial.
Some of Mr. Kelly's steadfast supporters continue to believe he is the victim of a larger, racist conspiracy to keep successful Black men from thriving, and that view was once more than widespread in Black communities earlier his trial, experts note.
Equally a former goggle box critic at The New York Times, Aisha Harris, said, ii cultural touchstones — "Chappelle's Testify" and "The Boondocks" — also helped shape the perception of the accusations against R. Kelly through humor, keeping audiences tickled instead of troubled.
The cultural climate has also inverse dramatically since the allegations confronting Mr. Kelly first began to surface. Later the vocalizer pleaded not guilty to the charges that led to his 2008 trial, he performed alongside children at a church in Chicago the aforementioned twenty-four hour period. He was embraced past the congregation.
Sept. 27, 2021, 6:42 p.m. ET
R. Kelly will be sentenced in May, every bit other criminal charges motion forward.
Image
R. Kelly is gear up to be sentenced at 10 a.one thousand. on May 4 by the same federal estimate who oversaw his racketeering and sexual activity trafficking trial in Brooklyn. Mr. Kelly, 54, faces 10 years to life in prison.
The intervening months will be decorated. In the side by side few weeks, Mr. Kelly's lawyers can file motions seeking to overturn the verdict. Mr. Kelly also faces charges in at least two other states, including federal child pornography and obstruction counts in Chicago. That trial has been postponed several times, and a new date has not been fix. A court briefing in that instance has been set for Oct. twenty.
Mr. Kelly's lawyer said he didn't know if that trial would go forward before the sentencing, or if Mr. Kelly would be moved to Chicago from the Brooklyn detention facility where he has been held for the duration of the New York trial. But the Chicago case will go on, and it is likely that Mr. Kelly will eventually be moved there to face up those charges.
At the Brooklyn sentencing, Estimate Ann Chiliad. Donnelly will be able to consider victim-impact statements and testimony from Mr. Kelly's accusers, some of which will be filed with the court alee of time.
Sept. 27, 2021, 6:18 p.m. ET
Prosecutors thank R. Kelly's accusers, saying verdict 'forever brands' him as a predator.
Video
transcript
transcript
Verdict 'Forever Brands' R. Kelly a Predator, Prosecutor Says
Federal prosecutors thanked the witnesses who testified against R. Kelly and commended the bravery of his victims after the singer was establish guilty of running a decades-long scheme to recruit women and underage girls for sex.
-
"Today's guilty verdict forever brands R. Kelly as a predator who used his fame and fortune to prey on the immature, the vulnerable and the voiceless for his own sexual gratification. To the victims in this case, your voices were heard and justice was finally served. This confidence would not accept been possible without the bravery and resilience of R. Kelly'south victims. I applaud their courage in revealing in open court the painful, intimate and horrific details of their lives with him. No one deserves what they experienced at his easily, or the threats and harassment they faced in telling the truth about what happened to them." "Mr. Kelly is a prolific series predator. Despite numerous reports of his subversive abuse over the years, Mr. Kelly's brazen acts of intimidation against his accusers kept him shielded from prosecution. In their failed try to evade justice, Mr. Kelly and his associates made i critical error. They underestimated the resilience and courage of the victims who refused to be silenced."
Afterward a New York jury convicted R. Kelly on all nine charges against him, federal prosecutors had a uncomplicated message for the people who testified confronting him: Thank yous.
"Today's guilty verdict forever brands R. Kelly as a predator who used his fame and fortune to prey on the young, the vulnerable and the voiceless for his own gratification," Jacquelyn M. Kasulis, the acting U.S. attorney in Brooklyn, told a crowd of reporters and onlookers outside the federal courthouse on Monday.
She added: "We hope that today'due south verdict brings some measure out of comfort and closure to his victims."
The commencement accusations against Mr. Kelly date dorsum to the early 1990s, but he evaded criminal prosecution for years, even as additional women came forwards, and he was acquitted of child pornography in 2008 after a sex-tape came to light that the government said depicted him with a fifteen-twelvemonth-onetime girl.
Ms. Kasulis said that Mr. Kelly'due south confidence on Monday delivered a powerful message to both the entertainer and other influential men: "No matter how long it takes, the long arm of the law will catch up with you."
Addressing what he called a "decades-long reign of terror" inflicted by Mr. Kelly, Peter Fitzhugh, a special agent-in-charge at Homeland Security Investigations, the investigative arm of the Department of Homeland Security, said that the singer "made one disquisitional mistake."
"He underestimated the resilience and courage of the victims who refused to be silenced," Mr. Fitzhugh said.
He added that he hoped the women and men who testified against the singer could now begin a "healing procedure" and restore the aspects of their lives that Mr. Kelly had destroyed.
Sept. 27, 2021, 6:12 p.chiliad. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
Kim Foxx, the top prosecutor in Chicago who announced state sex crime charges against him in that location in 2019, told me she believes R. Kelly's conviction was "monumental" for the Me Too movement and sends a meaning message nigh whose stories affair. "It is my hope that through this trial and the toll that it has taken to get to this point, that nosotros recognize that the motility is not at its fullest force if everyone doesn't take equal admission to justice," she said.
Sept. 27, 2021, 5:54 p.m. ET
R. Kelly made his victims write letters exonerating him. Instead, they helped convict him.
Image
Much of the testify that prosecutors used to convict R. Kelly came from the singer himself.
He obsessively collected message slips and letters written by the women he interacted with — some of them underage — according to Ryan Chabot, the lead federal investigator in the case. Mr. Chabot said he sifted through the prove recovered from several searches of the singer's Chicago apartment and storage facility.
Mr. Kelly kept some of the evidence in FedEx folders, with labels like "Quondam Letters," and other pieces — like a 7-page, front-and-dorsum, handwritten letter of the alphabet from a woman who testified for three days early on in the trial — in protective sleeves in a locked safety.
Calling Mr. Kelly a "great man," the woman wrote: "At the age of 17 I never had sex activity with Robert Kelly," then proceeded to tick off a listing of specific sex acts that she said she had not participated in with the R&B superstar.
Less than two years later, when the woman who had written the letter of the alphabet testified nether a pseudonym, she said she had experienced coerced and recorded sexual encounters with the vocalizer starting when she was 17. He hit her oft, she said, and forced her to become an ballgame.
Every letter of the alphabet that prosecutors introduced at trial came from Mr. Kelly's personal collection in what appeared to exist a yearslong attempt to build his defense force even before the indictment in Brooklyn was unsealed. They were all signed by accusers who were at the forefront of the case against the vocalizer.
Those accusers now say he forced them to write the messages, including a man who testified that the singer told him what to write "word for discussion."
The material, known every bit "collateral," makes it difficult for victims to escape, said Dawn Thousand. Hughes, a clinical and forensic psychologist who provided expert testimony for the prosecution. (She also testified every bit an skillful at the trial of Keith Raniere, the Nxivm cult leader, who besides relied on such collateral to intimidate women he was abusing.)
Creating collateral keeps adolescents "captive," she said, and creates a power dynamic she likened to "slowly sucking the oxygen out of the room and once you realize it, you lot can't go out."
Sept. 27, 2021, five:36 p.chiliad. ET
Gloria Allred, lawyer for survivors, says 'justice has been done.'
Video
transcript
transcript
'Justice Has Been Washed,' Allred Says
Gloria Allred, the famed women'south rights attorney who represented several of R. Kelly's victims, said Mr. Kelly was the worst of all the sexual predators she had pursued in her career.
-
I have pursued many sexual predators who have committed crimes against women and children. Of all the predators that I take pursued, even so, Mr. Kelly is the worst, for many reasons. First, he used the power of his celebrity to recruit vulnerable, underage girls for the purpose of sexually abusing them. These were non May- October relationships, which is what his defense attorney wanted the jury to believe. These were crimes confronting children and some adults. Second, he used the ability of his business enterprise, and many of his inner circumvolve employees, to assistance him and enable him in his plan and his scheme to lure his victims to him, isolate them, intimidate them, control them, indoctrinate them, punish them, shame them and humiliate them. R. Kelly'south victims handled themselves with nobility and survived intense cantankerous-examination by the defence. Considering of their courage and the outstanding piece of work of federal agents and prosecutors in this case, justice has been done. Let this be a bulletin to other celebrities who also utilize their fame to prey on their fans and others who are unfortunate enough to come into contact with them. You're also likely to confront serious consequences for your criminal conduct. The event is non if the law will grab up to you. The only question is when.
Shortly afterwards a jury found R. Kelly guilty of a decades-long scheme to recruit women and teenage girls for sex, Gloria Allred, a women's rights chaser who represented several of the singer'south accusers, stood outside the federal courthouse in Brooklyn and declared "justice has been done."
Ms. Allred has ofttimes represented women who accept been victims of sexual harassment and sexual assault by powerful men — including in the instance against the movie producer Harvey Weinstein. Just she said that "of all the predators that I have pursued, Mr. Kelly is the worst."
Mr. Kelly used his celebrity to dispense and sexually abuse underage girls, Ms. Allred said, and had used a network of enablers to help build and sustain that world of torment and abuse. Mr. Kelly besides knowingly spread herpes to his victims, she said.
Ms. Allred represented three of the six victims whose accounts were at the center of the instance, likewise as two other key witnesses in the trial. She too represented a tertiary who in the end was not called to testify.
"Allow this be a bulletin to other celebrities who also use their fame to prey on their fans," Ms. Allred said. "The event is not if the police force volition catch upwards to you, the only question is when."
Jacquelyn Kasulis, acting attorney for the Eastern District of New York, also spoke at the news conference, applauding the verdict and the "bravery and resilience" of survivors whose testimony was fundamental to the example against Mr. Kelly.
Sept. 27, 2021, 5:09 p.m. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
Sparkle, the vocalist who testified that her niece was the underage daughter at the heart of R. Kelly'southward trial in 2008, told me later on his conviction that she was feeling a "bevy of emotions" as her vox broke over the phone. "Information technology's a good day. It'due south a pitiful 24-hour interval. It'south simply the fact that my niece and the other young women can now feel a sense of relief — he'south not able to practise this to them whatsoever longer."
Sept. 27, 2021, 4:54 p.m. ET
Outside the courthouse, R. Kelly's die-hard fans react to guilty verdict with outrage.
Image
Outside the federal courthouse in Brooklyn, a small group of R. Kelly supporters greeted Monday's guilty verdict with outrage, citing unproven claims of a biased prosecution.
"We are not giving up," one woman shouted into a megaphone, as Mr. Kelly's lawyers left the courthouse Monday afternoon. "Free Robert Sylvester Kelly."
"This is a racist country," another said. (Mr. Kelly, similar many of the women and men who testified against him, is Blackness.)
Equally dozens of accusations against R. Kelly spilled over into public view in recent years, Mr. Kelly's reputation has deteriorated. Only a steadfast grouping of supporters maintains that he is innocent, with some attending each day of his racketeering trial in New York.
The group remained relatively small throughout the six-week trial, and oft gathered outside the courthouse before the 24-hour interval's proceedings began. Some crafted chalk art including the words "Complimentary R. Kelly" on a nearby sidewalk. Others waited in line to be among the offset to enter the building when it opened.
During breaks, the fervent group oft streamed the singer'southward music on a loudspeaker in a park across the street from the courthouse. Some spoke with followers on social media live-streams and offered updates on the day's testimony.
And when the days ended, many cheered and shook easily with Mr. Kelly'south defense lawyers while jeering federal prosecutors as they left the edifice.
Much of Mr. Kelly'south current fan base lives in and around Chicago, his hometown, where he in one case was seen every bit a success story, someone who overcame a low-income upbringing filled with struggles. Several of the supporters who have attended the New York trial flew from Illinois to follow the case.
A handful of supporters claimed seats each day in the back of the courtroom where the public and reporters could lookout the proceedings via closed-circuit video. They often reacted out loud to the government'south witnesses and to the counterarguments of Mr. Kelly's defense lawyers.
At times, it landed them it trouble.
After a prosecutor said that there had been "audible, negative reactions to testimony" and that the father of one accuser had been verbally accosted, Judge Ann Thou. Donnelly, who presided over the trial, warned visitors that they would lose access to the courthouse if they did not "behave."
Emily Palmer contributed reporting.
Sept. 27, 2021, iv:44 p.g. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
The "Surviving R. Kelly" documentary on Lifetime was key to bringing awareness to the charges against the singer. After the verdict, Dream Hampton, the product's executive producer, said on Twitter that she was "grateful to the survivors. The ones who talked and the ones who didn't."
Sept. 27, 2021, iv:28 p.m. ET
The 'Surviving R. Kelly' documentary catalyzed the case against the singer.
Epitome
R. Kelly's trial has taken place backside airtight doors, away from the press and the public. Only even before his trial and conviction on Monday, the country had already heard the searing allegations of sexual, emotional and physical abuse leveled against the singer.
A 2022 Lifetime documentary serial, "Surviving R. Kelly," featured six hourlong episodes that included the stories of some of the women who said they were abused and manipulated by Mr. Kelly, oft when they were underage.
"It makes a departure when there are cameras involved, and when people can actually see these women telling their stories and feel it," said Dream Hampton, an executive producer of the documentary.
The trail of allegations against Mr. Kelly was start examined through reporting that starting time emerged in the early 2000s past Jim DeRogatis, a music critic at The Chicago-Sun Times. And in 2008, Mr. Kelly was tried and acquitted in a criminal court in Chicago in a loftier-profile child pornography case. Years later, Mr. DeRogatis went on to publish several more than damning and widely shared articles.
But information technology was the documentary — emerging amidst the broader Me Too movement'southward reckoning over sexual abuse by powerful men — that finally batty Mr. Kelly'southward career.
The series was followed past criminal charges against the singer in Minnesota, Illinois and New York at the federal and land levels. RCA, Mr. Kelly's record label, and its parent company Sony Music Entertainment cut him loose.
On Monday, Mr. Kelly was convicted on all charges. When he is sentenced in May, he faces life in prison.
Merely the case does not stop when a verdict is reached, Ms. Hampton said.
"Peer accountability actually is the true stop hither," Ms. Hampton said.
Sept. 27, 2021, 4:xix p.one thousand. ET
R. Kelly'southward trial could get music'southward #MeToo moment.
Prototype
When the #MeToo motion began sweeping through Hollywood, politics and the business concern world in 2017, people in the music manufacture — where unsupervised contact between male stars and young female fans is so common as to be mythologized — wondered when accountability would reach their shores.
The music business has indeed had its share of scandals in recent years. The singers Marilyn Manson and Ryan Adams, and the hip-hop mogul Russell Simmons, have been defendant of diverse kinds of misconduct.
Only the criminal trial of R. Kelly, which ended with his confidence on Mon, has been by far the most high profile #MeToo moment in music. To a dandy degree, that is a effect of the serious nature of the charges that federal prosecutors brought against him, and of the fact that Mr. Kelly was accused of engaging in sex acts with women and girls as young every bit thirteen or 14.
But similar accusations against Mr. Kelly take been public for decades, publicized through reporting in The Chicago Sun-Times in the early 2000s and at a child pornography trial in 2008, where he was acquitted. For years, Mr. Kelly remained signed to a major record label, where he sold millions of albums and maintained his status as a meridian-level hitmaker. Stars like Lady Gaga, Jay-Z, Conductor and Chance the Rapper worked with him; in 2013, he performed at the Pitchfork Festival in Chicago, a home for hipster-canonical indie stone.
That Mr. Kelly avoided banishment from the music world for then long — and, indeed, that he was embraced by that world — has been seen as a stain against the manufacture. It was just in 2022 that public opinion began to plow decisively against Mr. Kelly. That was when BuzzFeed News began to publish a series of investigative reports by Jim DeRogatis, a journalist who had chronicled the accusations confronting Mr. Kelly at The Sun-Times years before.
In early 2019, afterward the broadcast of the documentary "Surviving R. Kelly," featuring stomach-turning firsthand accounts by numerous women, Mr. Kelly was finally dropped by RCA, his label. By then, Mr. Kelly had non had a hit in a number of years.
Today, Mr. Kelly has been largely shunned by the music industry at large; Lady Gaga, for instance, apologized for working with him and removed the track they recorded together in 2013. But Mr. Kelly'due south catalog is even so available on streaming services. Its popularity in that location — on Spotify, his music draws five.ii million listeners each month — suggests a fan base that has never left.
Sept. 27, 2021, 4:15 p.m. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
Jerhonda Pace, the first accuser to testify against R. Kelly at the trial, was i of the earliest women to go public with her accusations in 2017. On Monday, she reacted with a simple message on Instagram, writing "Verdict? GUILTY."
Sept. 27, 2021, 4:13 p.m. ET
covers the courts in New York
Racketeering cases against individual defendants are rare. This racketeering charge against R. Kelly required prosecutors to show that the singer was the leader of an ongoing criminal enterprise involving multiple enablers, even though he was the sole defendant on trial.
Sept. 27, 2021, 4:09 p.m. ET
R. Kelly'due south lawyer says the case was 'replete with inconsistencies.'
Video
transcript
transcript
R. Kelly 'Disappointed' past the Verdict, His Lawyer Says
Deveraux L. Cannick, R. Kelly'southward lawyer, said the defense team would appeal the vocalist'south guilty verdict later he was institute guilty of racketeering and 8 counts of sex trafficking.
-
"Of class, Mr. Kelly is disappointed. He was not anticipating this verdict because based on the evidence, why should he anticipate this verdict? When you lot go with the discovery, you saw witness after witnesses giving three, four, five unlike versions equally to what they said happened here. The regime scarlet-picked the version that they thought would be a continuation of the narrative that was first put out past Cheryl Mack and 'Surviving R. Kelly,' and they reddish-picked a version and ran with that version. They totally ignore the inconsistencies that all of these witnesses gave in their debriefing. They endeavour, and I guess they successfully did it, was to massage it. But information technology's a situation we are in. I didn't know if I'yard more disappointed in the jurors' verdict or the government's action in this case. Thank you very much." "Reporter: What did your client say to you as soon as the verdict was read?" "I'm certain. I'yard sure we'll be appealing."
Equally he left the courtroom, R. Kelly's lawyer said the defence force squad would consider appealing the verdict that could send his star client to prison for life.
"Of form we are disappointed in the verdict," the lawyer, Deveraux L. Cannick, said every bit he walked through the courthouse. "I am fifty-fifty more than disappointed in the prosecution for bringing this case," he said, calculation that information technology was "replete with inconsistencies."
Just jurors found the witnesses credible, and convicted Mr. Kelly on all charges.
Asked if Mr. Kelly was prepared for the confidence, Mr. Cannick said: "I don't think everyone is ever prepared for an outcome like this."
Mr. Cannick stepped exterior the courthouse, where dozens of reporters and photographic camera crews had been stationed all day in anticipation of a verdict. He and other members of the defence team strode past the microphones gear up upwardly for a news conference and into the adjacent park, where he was speedily ambushed by cameras and microphones.
Speaking equally he walked, Mr. Cannick told the cameras that "witness later witness had given three, four, five different versions" of their stories.
Sept. 27, 2021, iv:07 p.one thousand. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
One important takeaway from the verdict: What it could hateful to the family unit of the vocaliser Aaliyah, who died in 2001. Jurors found R. Kelly responsible for the ransom of a government employee that allowed him to ally Aaliyah in 1994 when she was 15.
Sept. 27, 2021, 4:03 p.chiliad. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
Jacquelyn One thousand. Kasulis, the acting U.S. chaser in Brooklyn, thanked the 11 men and women who accused R. Kelly of misconduct at the trial: "No one deserves what they experienced at his hands or the threats and harassment they faced in telling the truth about what happened to them. We hope that today'southward verdict brings some measure of condolement and closure."
Prototype
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:59 p.yard. ET
reporting from the courthouse
A handful of reporters were allowed into the actual court for the verdict, and we were able to see the jury and R. Kelly's reaction. The but movement I could notice from Mr. Kelly was the occasional clench of his jaw; his optics seemed to be looking directly alee at the tabular array. At the end, he stood and buttoned his suit as the jury filed out through a side door.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:57 p.m. ET
A adult female who testified confronting R. Kelly in 2008 called the trial 'a big relief.'
Epitome
The singer Sparkle was hopeful that R. Kelly could elevate her 12-year-one-time niece, an aspiring rapper, to success when she introduced the daughter and other family unit members to the R&B star.
Merely years later, she would evidence at Mr. Kelly's kickoff criminal trial that a sex record at the heart of the case showed Mr. Kelly having sex with and urinating on her teenage niece.
It was not enough for jurors, and the vocaliser was acquitted of child pornography charges in 2008.
On Monday, she said she was feeling "a bevy of emotions" later Mr. Kelly was finally found guilty of sex-trafficking and racketeering charges on Monday, 20 years later she was first approached past a lawyer over the sex activity record involving her niece.
"It's a skillful day. It's a sad day," she said, her voice breaking. "Information technology's just the fact that my niece and the other young women can now feel a sense of relief — he'southward not able to do this to them any longer."
In an earlier interview in the days before the singer'south confidence, she described the case equally "a big relief" and an enormous "release" of the regrets, hardships and frustrations she has held for decades.
"I take been carrying this since 2001," Sparkle, whose real name is Stephanie Edwards, said in an interview in the days before the verdict arrived. "Finally, I can have some sense of normal — whatever normal looks like on the other finish of this."
She added: "This was really something that I took and put on my shoulders. I'm needing massages every other day, because this thing has been heavy."
Sparkle was once R. Kelly's protégée, providing backup vocals for Aaliyah'south debut anthology and releasing her own showtime album in 1998. The two records were both produced by Mr. Kelly, and hers went gold.
When Sparkle testified at Mr. Kelly'due south first trial, her sister — the mother of her niece — maintained that the teenager in the sex tape was not her daughter. Her testimony fractured the family and her promising music career never fully recovered after the trial.
In its aftermath, Sparkle said her relationships with family members briefly recovered, before further deteriorating after she participated in the "Surviving R. Kelly" documentary.
"I don't desire to say happy because it's not really a happy moment," Sparkle said. "You but can't even empathise what my family has gone through."
She added: "I don't know that it will ever be the same."
She said it was "mind-extraordinary" that the singer'due south abuses spanned more than three decades, and emphasized that those around Mr. Kelly who allowed his beliefs to go along were also to blame. "They helped this human do all of this stuff to these immature girls," she said. "Shame on them."
Her niece, now a adult female in her 30s, has cooperated with federal prosecutors in Chicago in recent years in their own case against the singer. Sparkle said she was not certain how she had been processing the singer'southward current trial.
"Just I hope she'southward able to live a piddling bit more," Sparkle said. "Fifty-fifty if she gets recognized, to non have such a backlash. I'm just hopeful that information technology's all over."
She added: "I wish and I pray that moving forward that Black women are listened to."
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:49 p.yard. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
Outside the courthouse, Gloria Allred, a lawyer for several of R. Kelly's accusers, praised the verdict and addressed the 3 decades of accusations it took for Mr. Kelly to be convicted: "We understand that justice moves at a glacial footstep."
Image
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:47 p.k. ET
covers the music industry
Past accusing R. Kelly of running a criminal enterprise, prosecutors focused on his entourage — the managers, handlers and contrasted employees who accept helped him procure immature women and avert consequences. The sad truth is that this is not uncommon in the music world. I question is whether Mr. Kelly's conviction will change that.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:46 p.m. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
A major question at present: What happens to the other criminal cases against R. Kelly? He faces another federal case in Chicago — which could tack on decades to a prison term — along with state sex activity crime charges in Illinois and Minnesota.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:44 p.m. ET
reporting from the courthouse
R. Kelly's lawyers left the courthouse and were thronged past reporters and cameras. They were trailed by a few supporters of Mr. Kelly'southward, ane of whom spoke into a megaphone: "We are not giving upwardly! No Justice!"
Image
Sept. 27, 2021, iii:42 p.thou. ET
reporting from the courthouse
Dressed in a blue accommodate and white mask, R. Kelly listened with his head down, eyes cast down. The jury looked upwards at the judge betwixt each announcement of "guilty." When defence force asked for a poll, each juror responded with a variety of "yes." Not a single one hesitated.
Sept. 27, 2021, iii:38 p.m. ET
covers the courts in New York
The guilty verdict came swiftly, particularly given the complexity of the case against R. Kelly and the lengthy trial.
Image
Sept. 27, 2021, three:37 p.1000. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
R. Kelly'southward sentencing hearing is scheduled for May 4, 2022. He could spend the residual of his life in prison, representing a remarkable downfall for the vocalist who once stood atop the world of R&B.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:36 p.m. ET
Five takeaways from the R. Kelly guilty verdict.
Epitome
The vocalist R. Kelly could spend decades in prison after a jury convicted him of racketeering and eight violations of an anti-sexual practice-trafficking police force.
Here are a few takeaways from the verdict:
1. Prosecutors congenital a much stronger example than in 2008.
The government presented a sweeping case that featured xi accusers, nine women and two men. Many of their accounts were bolstered by show, and the allegations spanned decades.
It gave jurors a low chance of reaching a total acquittal in the trial, legal experts said. When Mr. Kelly was acquitted of state child pornography charges in Chicago in 2008, jurors said that the absenteeism of testimony from the daughter at the center of the case spurred doubts.
two. An unusual approach to the accusations against Mr. Kelly proved successful.
Racketeering cases are ofttimes used confronting mob organizations. So when the charge was employed against Mr. Kelly, some legal experts viewed information technology as a potentially precarious approach: Would jurors believe that employees who promoted a music business also served every bit the henchmen of a criminal enterprise at the vocalist's command?
Ultimately, they did. And some experts on sexual abuse saw value in placing the enablers around a powerful man at the middle of his trial.
3. The jurors accepted the accounts of the government'due south first master accuser, Jerhonda Stride.
Ms. Pace, who was one of the earliest women to go public with her accusations in a 2022 BuzzFeed article, told jurors that Mr. Kelly had begun having sex with her in 2009, when she was 16. She said he one time choked her until she passed out after she disobeyed i of his rules, and and then forced her to perform a sexual practice act on him.
The singer's defense squad attempted to depict her every bit "a super-stalker," "a super-hustler," and "a groupie extraordinaire." Only jurors plain disagreed, and found that prosecutors proved all three underlying accusations in the racketeering charge that pertained to Ms. Footstep.
After the jury's decision was announced, Ms. Footstep posted a message on Instagram: "Verdict? GUILTY."
4. A woman who spoke publicly for the first time was believed.
One of the six women at the center of Mr. Kelly'south trial had never spoken publicly about their accusations: Stephanie, who took the stand using but her first proper noun. Her encounters with Mr. Kelly occurred in the late 1990s, and Mr. Kelly's defense lawyers questioned why they did not come forward sooner.
But judging from the verdict, jurors believed her account. She testified that Mr. Kelly began sexually abusing her when she was 17.
5. 1 accuser initially dedicated Mr. Kelly afterwards he faced legal troubles. Simply jurors saw her as his victim.
One adult female, who testified under a pseudonym, initially had come to his defense in a television interview in 2019. Mr. Kelly's lawyers spent more than time cantankerous-examining her than any other witness and homed in on discrepancies in her accounts over fourth dimension.
But ultimately her testimony — which included some of the well-nigh graphic accusations confronting Mr. Kelly — appeared to exist largely believed, with jurors finding Mr. Kelly guilty of all four counts related to her.
Sept. 27, 2021, iii:32 p.m. ET
covers the music industry
With R. Kelly found guilty, the big question for the music industry is whether his music will at present be removed from major digital platforms similar Spotify and Apple Music. Although nigh digital outlets have policies disallowment hate speech, they tend to take a hands-off approach when information technology comes to removing cloth, seeing themselves as neutral platforms and not censors.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:32 p.grand. ET
Depending on your view of tech companies, that conclusion tin can exist loftier-minded and principled, or merely a mode to avoid the slippery slope of policing their platforms. Even when Spotify instituted a "hateful conduct" policy in 2018, they did not delete the artists's songs. The policy came under burn down as capricious, and disproportionately affecting Blackness artists, and was rescinded after a few weeks.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:27 p.m. ET
covers pop music
Major figures in music — including A-list R. Kelly collaborators like Jay-Z, Lady Gaga, Justin Bieber and Take a chance the Rapper — have been largely mum about the trial. I'thousand eager to meet how that calculus changes at present that there'southward a guilty verdict.
Sept. 27, 2021, iii:26 p.m. ET
R. Kelly's conviction represents a major #MeToo moment for Black women.
Image
When the #MeToo movement erupted years ago, scores of women spoke out against the powerful men, igniting a national reckoning over sexual abuse and harassment.
Just as cases of high-profile men like the Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein put a spotlight on the accusations of white women, Black women frequently said they felt left out of the conversation.
For many, R. Kelly's case and conviction offered the sense that the motion could serve them, too, giving them a chance to hold men answerable.
"This is culmination of the motility of and so many women who having existence trying so long to have their voices heard," said Oronike Odeleye, the co-founder of the #MuteRKelly campaign. "We have never had full ownership of our bodies. And nosotros're at a moment where Black women are no longer accepting that as the price of existence Blackness and female person in America."
The activist Tarana Burke started the original iteration of "Me Too" effectually 2007, using the phrase to raise awareness of sexual assail and connect victims to resources. But when the actress Alyssa Milano tweeted the words "me likewise" a decade afterwards, initially without crediting Ms. Shush, some observers worried that Black women had been left out of the story and noted that Ms. Burke'south initial endeavour had not been supported past prominent white feminists.
Now, the jurors' credence of the stories of Mr. Kelly's accusers holds a deep significance, several experts say, particularly because Blackness women and girls take historically seen their accusations dismissed more often than others.
"When you have girls who aren't famous, they're not stars in their ain right — and they're Black — information technology becomes so piece of cake for people to overlook their suffering and to cast it bated so the status quo tin exist preserved," said Deborah Tuerkheimer, a professor of law at Northwestern University and erstwhile assistant district chaser in Manhattan.
Whitney Davis, 34, said she has followed other major #MeToo cases. Merely Mr. Kelly'due south trial carried a singled-out resonance for a confluence of a reasons, she said: The accusers at the heart of the case looked similar her, and she had herself endured sexual corruption in childhood.
"To be honest, this was the first instance that was predominantly Black girls, Black women, Black boys — and so information technology was intriguing to me to run across if they would get justice," said Ms. Davis, who is from Dallas. "To see justice for them, oh, my God, information technology will in a way mean justice for myself."
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:23 p.m. ET
covers pop music
This is past far the highest-profile, post-Me Too conviction involving sexual corruption that we've seen in the music industry. Its bear on — and the fact that the prosecution secured a guilty verdict across the board — is only heightened by the fact of R. Kelly's offset acquittal on child pornography charges in 2008 allowed for his career to keep flourishing in the years that followed.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:21 p.m. ET
covers criminal justice in New York
R. Kelly sat motionless in the courtroom as he was institute guilty of all nine counts of the racketeering and sex activity-trafficking charges confronting him. His facial expression was hidden by a mask.
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:13 p.1000. ET
covers the courts in New York
Relatively brief deliberations in a circuitous case tin can like this often indicate that the jury was fairly united in reaction to the trial.
Sept. 27, 2021, three:12 p.m. ET
R. Kelly Is Convicted of All Counts After Decades of Accusations of Corruption
Video
transcript
transcript
R. Kelly Found Guilty on All Counts
The vocalist was bedevilled of federal racketeering and sex trafficking charges for a decades-long scheme to recruit women and underage girls for sex. Once ane of the biggest names in popular music, he could face decades in prison house.
-
"Today'southward guilty verdict forever brands R. Kelly as a predator who used his fame and fortune to prey on the young, the vulnerable and the voiceless." "Mr. Kelly is a prolific serial predator. Despite numerous reports of his destructive abuse over the years, Mr. Kelly'due south brazen acts of intimidation confronting his accusers kept him shielded from prosecution." "Kelly, after training, isolating and intimidating his child victims, recorded them beingness sexually abused and humiliated by him. He directed these videos and produced them, not just for his own sexual gratification, but in some instances for the purpose of using these videos to silence and threaten his victims with public exposure of these tapes if they ever revealed what he had done to them." "Of course, Mr. Kelly is disappointed. He was non anticipating this verdict considering based on the evidence, why should he conceptualize this verdict? I'm sure — I'yard sure we'll exist appealing."
R. Kelly, the multiplatinum R&B artist whose musical legacy became intertwined with dozens of accusations of sexual abuse, was found guilty on Mon of serving as the ringleader of a decades-long scheme to recruit women and underage girls for sex.
The jury in New York deliberated for about ix hours before convicting the singer of all nine counts against him, including racketeering and 8 violations of an anti-sex activity trafficking law known as the Mann Human activity.
The conclusion represents the start criminal punishment confronting Mr. Kelly despite a trail of allegations of misconduct that extends for more a quarter-century. His half-dozen-calendar week trial exposed a harrowing system of trauma and corruption, allowable by the singer and enabled by his associates.
Mr. Kelly, 54, once one of the biggest names in popular music, now faces the possibility of life in prison, capping a remarkable reversal of fortune. As the verdict was read, he sat motionless in the court, wearing a navy blueish suit and glasses, with his facial expression hidden backside a mask.
To many observers, Mr. Kelly's case represented a critical exam of the inclusivity of the Me Likewise movement, which seeks to hold influential and powerful men accountable for sexual misbehavior. Never before in a high-profile Me Too-era trial had the large majority of the accusers been Black women.
Jacquelyn M. Kasulis, the acting U.S. chaser in Brooklyn, told reporters that the verdict sent a powerful bulletin to men like Mr. Kelly.
She thanked the eleven men and women who accused him of misconduct at the trial.
"No ane deserves what they experienced at his hands or the threats and harassment they faced in telling the truth about what happened to them. Nosotros promise that today's verdict brings some measure of comfort and closure," Ms. Kasulis said.
As he left the courtroom on Mon, ane of Mr. Kelly's lawyers said his defense squad would consider an entreatment.
"Of course nosotros are disappointed in the verdict," the lawyer, Deveraux L. Cannick, said every bit he walked through the courthouse. "I am even more disappointed in the prosecution for bringing this example," he said, calculation that it was "replete with inconsistencies."
Mr. Kelly once stood atop the realm of R&B music, catapulting himself into an international sensation in the 1990s and 2000s on the success of hits like "I Believe I Can Wing."
But as the Me Too motility connected to gain steam, cracks in his armor began to show, as new women and their families came forwards, a protest campaign was waged to boycott his music and a jarring documentary delved into the accusations around him. The image he once crafted every bit an alluring sex symbol and genre-redefining lyricist collapsed in the public center.
The trial marked a meaning milestone, equally women and men took the stand confronting the vocalizer to accuse Mr. Kelly of sexual corruption for the first time, including several who had never shared their accounts publicly.
On Monday, several women who said Mr. Kelly had abused them praised his conviction every bit a decades-in-the-making rebuke of the singer and a meaningful validation of the stories of his victims.
"Today, my vocalization was heard," Jerhonda Footstep wrote on Instagram. Ms. Pace became the first accuser to always testify against Mr. Kelly at a criminal trial when she took the stand concluding month.
Oronike Odeleye, the co-founder of the #MuteRKelly campaign, said the conviction was the result of accusations that took years to exist heard.
"This is the culmination of the movement of so many women who take been trying and then long to take their voices heard," Ms. Odeleye said. "We have never had total ownership of our bodies. And we're at a moment where Black women are no longer accepting that as the toll of existence Black and female in America."
The verdict came afterwards the regime constructed a sweeping case against Mr. Kelly, with evidence that extended from recent years back to the early 1990s.
Federal prosecutors chronicled a dark journeying in the career of the singer, whose real proper name is Robert Sylvester Kelly. He was embraced every bit a hometown success story in Chicago as he overcame a low-income upbringing filled with struggles.
Just his eminence assured him he was untouchable, prosecutors said, and every bit he gained immense access to young fans, Mr. Kelly became a criminal mastermind who used a universe of enablers and sycophants in his orbit to ensnare women, girls and boys.
The prosecution called 45 witnesses during the trial, but the criminal charges against the singer hinged on accusations related to six women, five of whom testified (the sixth, the singer Aaliyah, died in a aeroplane crash in 2001).
4 additional women and two men likewise took the stand as accusers. And though none of their claims were included in the indictment, they helped bolster the government's arguments, oftentimes telling jurors that their encounters with the singer were marred by sexual, concrete or emotional abuse from him.
Throughout the proceedings, the result of Mr. Kelly's merely other criminal trial, in 2008, stood in mind for many observers. Prosecutors in Chicago had argued that a videotape showed him having sex with and urinating on an underage girl. Only he was acquitted of all 14 counts confronting him subsequently the girl at the center of the example declined to bear witness.
The singer's career flourished afterward with successful record sales and a consistent menstruation of collaborations with superstars. Just in recent years, his musical repertoire was largely expunged from the radio and public spaces, a fate that would likely persist with his conviction.
The regime was barred from detailing his previous case. But witnesses depicted an offender who was emboldened by his initial absolution — and whose behavior grew increasingly more than brazen and disturbing in the years that followed.
Cheerful fans saluted Mr. Kelly when he was cleared of wrongdoing in his Chicago trial. Simply just a pocket-sized ring of supporters was gathered outside the Brooklyn courthouse on Monday, where they streamed his music after the verdict was announced.
Mr. Kelly also faces a federal trial in Chicago on kid pornography and obstacle charges, and additional state sexual activity crime charges in Illinois and Minneapolis.
Kim Foxx, the summit prosecutor in Chicago who announced state sexual practice crime charges against Mr. Kelly in 2019, said the conviction was "monumental" for the Me Also move and sent a meaning message virtually whose stories mattered.
"It is my hope that through this trial and the toll that it has taken to become to this indicate, that we recognize that the movement is not at its fullest forcefulness if everyone doesn't have equal access to justice," she said.
In New York, the racketeering charge was viewed by some as an unusual and potentially precarious approach. Merely the statute, which has commonly been used to take down mob organizations, was recently employed successfully against the Nxivm sex cult.
Mr. Kelly's defense team said that the racketeering charge itself was flawed and unfounded, arguing that he had run nothing more than than a successful music business. But the government'due south case was expansive.
The charge was built effectually fourteen underlying crimes that he was accused of committing as part of his criminal enterprise; merely 2 of them needed to be proven to convict.
Mr. Kelly declined to prove in his own defense. Simply his lawyers aimed to bandage his accusers as opportunists, liars and obsessive fans, arguing their sex with the singer had been consensual, and their accounts of corruption and misconduct fabricated. They evoked images of him as an altruistic romantic partner who regarded the women around him as family, treated them "like gold" and was blindsided past their allegations.
And they warned that the accounts of his accusers had been besides inconsistent over time to believe.
"Getting a confidence of R. Kelly is a big deal," Mr. Cannick said in his summation, invoking Martin Luther Rex Jr. in an attempt to argue that if the jurors acquitted Mr. Kelly, they would be demonstrating the sort of courage that defined the civil rights movement. "What'south a bigger deal is a organisation we can trust."
But federal prosectors argued that a conviction would demonstrate that even the biggest stars were non untouchable by the law.
"The accused's victims aren't groupies or gold diggers. They're homo beings," Nadia Shihata, an assistant U.S. attorney, said at the terminate of the trial. "Daughters, sisters, some are at present mothers. And their lives thing."
The seven men and five women of the jury, whose ages and races were unclear throughout the trial, ultimately sided with their position. The group remained anonymous to the public and to lawyers at both tables in the courtroom.
Information technology featured an enormous pile of evidence, including text messages that showed the real-time worries that some of Mr. Kelly's employees shared virtually his treatment of women and several video and sound recordings, some of which appeared to depict the vocaliser violently assaulting a woman and threatening her life.
Still, the focal point of the case was its slate of witnesses, who told jurors the singer's public persona served to disguise his true intentions.
Among them were friends and family members of the singer's accusers; eight of his erstwhile employees; the government minister who presided over his union to Aaliyah; a doctor who treated him for herpes over more than a decade; and a host of investigators involved in his initial arrest in Chicago.
The trial itself represented a peculiar spectacle of the electric current moment.
Information technology was first scheduled for May 2020. But the pandemic delayed the start appointment for 15 months. And members of the public and the media were non granted access to the primary courtroom out of rubber concerns; they were required to watch the proceedings through closed-circuit video in overflow rooms.
Decades earlier the trial began, Mr. Kelly'due south union to Aaliyah in 1994, when she was 15 and he was 27, was amidst the first revelations to bring substantial public scrutiny to his encounters with underage girls. The racketeering case immune prosecutors the flexibility to innovate decades-erstwhile testify, including details related to Aaliyah, an R&B prodigy whose full proper name was Aaliyah Dana Haughton.
One of Mr. Kelly'southward former tour managers confirmed a long-rumored tale that he bribed a government employee to get a false identification for Aaliyah so the wedding could become forwards, because Mr. Kelly feared that she was significant and that he could be prosecuted for statutory rape.
Another woman, Stephanie, told jurors that the singer began sexually abusing her when she was 17, after he told her that he liked "young girls" and that he did not understand why lodge viewed that as a problem.
And a cascade of witnesses described a repressive organization of restrictions that the women and girls effectually Mr. Kelly were forced to bide by — from a directive to address him as "Daddy" to requirements to obtain his permission to consume or apply the bathroom.
They said that when the rules were broken, the singer doled out harsh and startling punishments, from pare-tearing spankings to forcing one woman to smear carrion on her face and eat it.
Mr. Cannick, the lawyer for Mr. Kelly, argued that the accounts were works of fiction and argued to jurors that the verdict carried deep implications for broader ethics of justice and fairness.
But Elizabeth Geddes, an assistant U.S. attorney, told the panel that their conclusion would serve to hold the fallen superstar accountable for the decades of hurting and torment he inflicted.
"For many years, what happened in the defendant's world stayed in the defendant'due south earth," Ms. Geddes said in her closing argument. "But no longer."
Emily Palmer and Rebecca Davis O'Brien contributed reporting.
Sept. 27, 2021, iii:eleven p.m. ET
After decades of accusations, R. Kelly's music is rarely heard on the radio at present.
Paradigm
For two decades R. Kelly has been at the center of accusations that he sexually driveling underage girls and immature women. But for nearly of that time, the accusations were non enough to derail his music career.
Only in recent years, equally Mr. Kelly has faced criminal charges in Illinois, Minnesota and New York, where he was found guilty on Monday of all counts, has a movement to boycott his songs, known equally the #MuteRKelly campaign, taken hold.
Earlier and so, Mr. Kelly's career thrived, even as the accusations against him became widely known. Even earlier 2000, when The Chicago Sun-Times published the first major investigation into allegations of abuse by Mr. Kelly, he had settled lawsuits accusing him of having sex activity with underage girls; in 1994, at 27, he had married Aaliyah, who was xv years one-time, allegedly using forged documents. Then in 2002, Mr. Kelly was indicted on child pornography charges subsequently a video surfaced that authorities said showed the vocalizer having sexual practice with a teenage daughter.
But Mr. Kelly connected to have success earlier, during and after the controversies, releasing 12 platinum albums in all. His fame was built on massive hits like "I Believe I Can Fly" in 1996 and "Ignition" in 2002. He collaborated with Jay-Z on two albums in 2002 and 2004. He was the featured artist on Lady Gaga's single "Practise What Yous Want" in 2013. And he was ane of two featured artists on Chance the Rapper'south song "Somewhere in Paradise" in 2015.
After his amortization of child pornography charges in 2008, it seemed every bit though Mr. Kelly'southward career was impenetrable to criticism.
The tables began to turn in 2022 when grass roots campaign emerged aimed at stopping his music from being played on radio stations, streaming services, and at concert venues. Oronike Odeleye, a co-founder of the move, said she started it "out of a feeling of outrage."
"This is well-nigh child sexual abuse and trauma that was inflicted on some of these women for years and years and years," Oronike Odeleye told The Times.
Mr. Kelly'due south tape label dropped him in 2019, after the broadcast of "Surviving R. Kelly," a documentary with firsthand accounts from women who said he had sexually abused them. Bout dates have been canceled, and Mr. Kelly has been in custody. And while he still garners 5.2 million listeners monthly on Spotify, it is unusual to hear his music played on the radio or in public.
Amid the controversy and trial, fans of Drake were outraged to learn that Mr. Kelly had gained a writing credit on the Canadian rapper's album "Certified Lover Boy."
The backlash to Mr. Kelly's function was so swift that Drake'southward longtime producer, Noah Shebib, issued an explanation on Instagram: One of Mr. Kelly'south songs was playing, barely audibly, in the groundwork of another clip in the song.
"Nosotros were forced to license it," Mr. Shebib wrote. "Doesn't sit well with me let me simply say that."
Sept. 27, 2021, 3:02 p.m. ET
Who is Ann Donnelly, the estimate in the R. Kelly case?
The judge presiding over R. Kelly's trial is best known for blocking one-time President Donald J. Trump's executive guild that barred refugees from entering the country in 2017. Judge Ann 1000. Donnelly ruled that the president'due south gild, which led to the detention of green card holders and other immigrants, would cause "irreparable harm" to the people displaced.
Before assuming her mail service in Brooklyn Federal Court, Approximate Donnelly worked as a lawyer in the New York County District Attorney'southward Part for 25 years, in roles including senior trial counsel, principal of the Family Violence and Kid Abuse Bureau, and a post in a bureau that specialized in dealing with repeat offenders and fierce felons.
In 2005 she won a conviction as lead prosecutor in a case finding Tyco chief executive L. Dennis Kozlowski guilty of looting almost $100 1000000 from his company.
Image
Four years later, she assumed her first judgeship in the New York Court of Claims and later moved on to several county supreme courts across New York City. Former President Barack Obama nominated Estimate Donnelly to her electric current post in 2015.
Over the past vi weeks, Estimate Donnelly has presided over strange occurrences during Mr. Kelly's trial, including a witness who tried to wriggle out of testifying despite a courtroom guild granting him immunity. Afterward ane of Mr. Kelly'due south defense lawyers dwelled on the topic of "twerking," Judge Donnelly reprimanded him in a sidebar away from jurors.
"Y'all need to become yourself here into 2022 with the residual of us, OK?" she said.
cervantezmarsureend.blogspot.com
Source: https://www.nytimes.com/live/2021/09/27/nyregion/r-kelly-trial-news
0 Response to "R Kelly in Legal Trouble Again"
Enregistrer un commentaire